Sunday, March 25, 2012

The Ubermenscher and Trayvon Martin

My favorite episode of The X Files is titled "Ubermenscher." In the episode, the Ubermenscher, a demonic entity called a tulpa in Tibet, was summoned from the Earth by Gene Gogolak to enforce his reign of terror on The Falls at Arcadia. Arcadia, in Greek mythology is the home of the god Pan, and an unspoiled, harmonious plane. In the episode, Arcadia is a harmonious, gated community where everyone is scrupulously careful to obey the rules and becomes very, very upset when any rule of decorum is broken. 

People start to disappear. People who just don't seem up to code. Clumsy people, odd people, anyone who deviates from the rules and regulation that make Arcadia pristine. Stray from the path or express any sense of individuality or eccentricity and an anonymous warning is issued. Your mistakes are corrected for you. Disobey again and the demonic Ubermenscher is dispatched to rise up out of the dirt and devour you. 


The Ubermenscher has no face. It is the summoned hatred and ignorance and will to maintain obedience and conformity of an entire community. 

Once the disappearances are reported, agents Mulder and Scully are dispatched to pretend to be a married company moving into Arcadia. Mulder soon begins tweeking the nose of the community by flouting the rules and acting in his typical eccentric way. But he finds his attempts to disrupt the harmony of Arcadia usurped at every turn. A mailbox he intentionally skews to one side is magically restored to its upright position while he goes to the bathroom. The secret helper who maintains order so obsessively is never seen. This wrankles Mulder, who goes on 24 hour watch to catch the super helper in the act. But he can't. 

No one ever does. The Ubermenscher comes from the collective will but no one person is ever held responsible for it. It's a manifestation of our collective neurosis that something or someone among us is ruining it for everyone by being deviant, odd, or upsetting the apple cart. 

In everyday life we encounter some comical examples of The Ubermenscher, like the obsessive compulsive legion of Wikipedia editors just waiting for someone out there to make any slightly askew statement about Ayn Rand or who appeared as an extra in episode seven of season three of Dr. Who so they can blow their whistle and scold the perpetrator about keeping their beautiful patch of the Universe unsullied. 

In politics we see more serious examples of people who would like to impose their morality on the rest of society with a Procrustean bed of laws designed to make the rest of us behave to the exact specifications of their God. Not ours, but theirs. All the Gods help us if these people ever have their way again. 

I'd like to keep my legs (and my own set or morals and ethics) thank you.

So, what are you on about this time, Thomas? Greek Gods, monsters, Procrustean beds, Wikipedia, what's the point?

On February 26, 2012, 17 year old Trayvon Martin was shot dead after being involved in a scuffle with self-appointed neighborhood watch captain George Zimmerman in the planned community of Sanford, Florida. Zimmerman claimed he shot Martin, who had reported via a 911 call as acting suspiciously, in an act of self defense. The facts of the case will probably never be clear, but what is known is that Zimmerman called 911 46 times in the year previous to the shooting, predominantly to report young, black males acting suspiciously. One of the calls was to report a child 7-9 years old. 

Already the facts of this matter have become virtually impossible to discern over the outrage of those who feel this is a tragic murder based on racism and those who believe law and order should be maintained at any price, but what seems clear to this writer is that America has become a very scary place where some people feel it is their God-given right, no, their God-appointed duty, to make sure the rest of us conform to their standards at all times. Act suspicious, stray from the lines only they can see for more than one step and you become suspicious, someone who needs to be followed, harassed, and ultimately weeded out.

Certainly an episode of The X Files is insufficient to convey the tragedy of what has happened here. The life lost. For no good reason other than one person wanting to decide who can and who can't walk freely in "his" community. But we've seen this before. We've seen it since the beginning. And we've never dealt with it. So it seeps into the water, the soil, the very Earth beneath our feet, and it waits, and it waits, and it waits. Then it rises like an amorphous golem of hatred and ignorance and snuffs out a life filled with promise and hope. 

People have always longed for that perfect place. Arcadia, Nirvana, Heaven, Elysium. And societies have always flirted with the idea that eliminating certain types of people would make life easier for everyone who wasn't one of those people. As one of those people I always remain wary that the pitchforks and torches will be out for me eventually. Or maybe you. Or maybe any one of us who isn't "them" enough. This battle needs to be continually fought because it has never been won and never goes away. 

Will there be justice for Trayvon Martin? I don't know. I know there's a war going on in America. A war that never really wasn't going on. A war I hope never breaks out into open violence in our streets over violations of humanity that were never punished and never atoned for. There seem to be people out there who not only are unwilling to atone, but never want that war to end. I don't want to live in a society like that. But I also feel it would be wrong to let those people continue living in ignorance and hatred, spewing their venom on the rest of us simply because it may be their "right" to be wrong. I'm not sure what the answer is. Maybe it might even be better to just fight it out. But I hold out hope something like reason or goodness or truth might save the day. 

Ask Pandora. There's always hope.



February 21, 2013 update: It seems I haven't heard anyone in my sphere even mentioned Trayvon Martin in months. Yet it seemed so important to so many people for about a week.

More things the Ubermenscher thinks you should or should not do. Or else.












Pin It

8 comments:

  1. Um. Hi. 'Ubermenscher' was used as a name as an ironic twist to what the world actually means (or comes from). But since you are apparently 13, with no real recourse of history, and relying on the frikkin X-Files, which are fiction based on previously used ideas, let me illuminate you.

    Ubermensch is German for 'Super Man' or 'Above Man', as created by Nietzsche's writings - particularly Thus Spoke Zarathustra. The Ubermensch is a transcendence of man - man's will moving him forward to achieve more from himself. Almost like self-evolution.

    X-Files used it in CLEARLY satirical ironic sense - not to mention, the episode sounds heavily borrowed from The Speford Wives (the original not the remake). And you, silly impressionable idiot, are now passing stupidity around and tying it to some topical distraction.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You mean The Stepford Wives, right? No, the conecpt of the Ubermenscher is NOT used in a satirical nature in this episode. It is used to show dark aspects of group social behavior such as we see in the Zimbardo prison experiment or Stanley Milgram's experiments on conforming to authority. In fact, in this episode only the title has any real resemblance or makes any allusion to Nietzsche's writings. You consider the Trayvon Martin case a "topical distraction?" It's important to be in control of the language one uses rather than just throwing around allusions inappropriately. But I would encourage you to go ahead and read Nietzsche, a very overrated and almost always misquoted philosopher.

    ReplyDelete
  3. l.bracy@hotmail.comApril 3, 2012 at 9:12 AM

    Nietzsche is overrated. A Topical Distraction is What the Trayvon Martin Case would be if it had happened in Rockford. Jessie would have left just as fast as he did in the Barmore shooting. Al Sharpton wouldn't have come, and there would have been no Hoodie protest phenom. As far as a cinematic or television based theme I think that ombie Logic prevails over Anonymous logic. The episode made a good allegory about the dangers tht can arise when you combine fear, stupidity and handguns. I hate to say it the film which the Trayvon Martin case reminds me of the most is Bonfire of The Vanities. Subs Tom Hanks Yuppie "gods of the universe" charecter for one bumbling paranoid wife beater and you have the martin case.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Maybe. But then you're bringing in the aspect of class warfare. The problem here doesn't seem to be class warfare, but people who just don't want to share their community with certain other types of people. I see this as a problem that's getting much worse, not better, even though I think for a few decades America was making improvement. Now there seems to be a small percentage of Americans (Conservatives) who are saying we're not even going to try and act like we're not racist anymore, rather we're just going to create our own communities where everyone looks and behave the way we do and raise our own militia and if you don't like it tough. What happens in Rockford tends to stay in Rockford, aside from a blurb on the news once every year or so.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Every weekend i used to go to see this web site, for the reason that i want enjoyment, since this this website conations in fact good funny material too.


    Visit my homepage ... understanding options trading

    ReplyDelete
  6. You know, you sure are right about that. I find that on many occasions this blog is bringing me pleasure on the weekends. It tends to be a little bit of a pain in the rubber parts during the week, but during the weekends, kablamo.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Everything you have said here is correct. Every frickin' word of it.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey! Do you use Twitter? I'd like to follow you if that would be okay. I'm definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new
    updates.

    Feel free to surf to my blog ... real money slots

    ReplyDelete

Blogger Wordpress Gadgets